Back to Resources
Hiring 7 min read

How to make an offer a candidate accepts

The offer is the stage most likely to lose a hire you have already won. What to say, how to handle negotiation, and how to hold an acceptance through to the first day.

Everything up to this point cost you weeks. The offer stage can undo it in an afternoon, and the ways it goes wrong are consistent and avoidable: a slow, silent gap after the final interview, a first number pitched low as a negotiating tactic, a written offer that quietly differs from what was discussed, and then four weeks of nothing between acceptance and the start date while a competitor keeps talking to them.

Knowing how to make a job offer well is largely about removing those four.

Call before you send anything

Make the offer on the phone, from the person the candidate will work for wherever possible.

An emailed offer arriving with no warning is a document. A call is a conversation, and it lets you do three things a document cannot: convey that you actually want them, hear their genuine first reaction, and find out immediately whether something is a problem.

Say the number on the call. Say what you valued about them specifically, not generically. Then confirm it in writing the same day, matching exactly what you said. Any gap between the verbal and the written offer reads as a bait and switch even when it is an administrative error.

Lead with your real number

The instinct to open low and keep room to move is a false economy in hiring.

A candidate who receives a lowball first offer learns something about how you value them, and that impression survives the negotiation even when you improve it. Some accept and start with a grievance. Some decline without countering, and you never learn why.

Decide the band during planning, pitch at what the person is genuinely worth to you within it, and keep a small amount of room for a reasonable counter. That is different from anchoring low on purpose.

Be consistent with what your existing team is paid. Paying a premium to close an external candidate creates an internal inequity that will surface, and when it does it costs you more than the hire saved.

Make the whole package legible

Salary is the headline and rarely the only thing that matters. Set out, clearly: base, any bonus or commission and how it is actually calculated, pension or superannuation, leave, flexibility and what it means in practice, and any genuine development budget.

Two rules. Do not inflate the total by counting statutory entitlements as benefits. And do not list anything you cannot deliver. A candidate who joins expecting two days from home and finds an unwritten five-day expectation will leave, and they will tell people why.

Handle the negotiation without drama

Most counters are modest and reasonable. Treat them as a normal part of the process rather than a challenge.

If you can meet it, meet it quickly. Speed communicates more goodwill than the money does. If you cannot, say so plainly and explain the constraint. "That sits above the band for this level and I cannot justify it against what the team is paid" is a respectable answer. Vagueness is not.

Where money is genuinely fixed, look at the things that are not: start date, leave, flexibility, review timing, title where it is honest, development budget. Frequently one of those closes the gap, because it was never only about the number.

Know your ceiling before the conversation starts, and hold it. A candidate negotiated beyond the band is an internal equity problem on day one.

Expect a counter-offer from their employer

If your candidate is any good, their current employer may try to keep them. Assume it and prepare for it rather than being surprised.

Raise it before it happens, without pressure. "If your employer counters, what would make you stay." The answer tells you what they actually want. If it is money alone, a counter-offer is a real risk. If they are leaving because of the manager or the lack of progression, a raise will not fix it and they usually know that.

Do not get into a bidding war. You will win an expensive employee who is still looking. What you can do is remind them why they started looking, which is the thing the counter-offer does not address.

Then keep talking to them. Silence between acceptance and start date is when counter-offers land.

The gap between acceptance and day one is not neutral

A signed acceptance is not a completed hire. Notice periods of four weeks to three months leave a long window in which a candidate can be approached, can get cold feet, or can simply drift away from a decision they made under enthusiasm.

Stay in contact. An introduction to the team, the manager checking in, sending something genuinely useful about what they will be working on. Not constant, but not nothing.

Get the administrative things done early rather than in the final week. Contract signed, equipment ordered, accounts ready, first week planned. A new starter who arrives to a desk with nothing on it and an IT ticket that has not been raised has learned something about how the place runs, on their first morning.

Have the first week planned before they arrive. That is where onboarding begins, and the plan matters more than the welcome pack.

Common questions

Should you make a verbal offer before the written one?

Yes. Call first, from the hiring manager, then confirm in writing the same day with identical terms.

What is a reasonable time to give a candidate to decide?

Enough to think properly, commonly a few days, and be guided by their situation. Artificial deadlines designed to force a decision damage the relationship and are a tactic good candidates recognise.

What if the candidate asks for more than your band?

Say so directly and explain the constraint. Then look at start date, leave, flexibility, review timing and development budget. Do not break the band, because the internal inequity costs more than the hire.

How do you stop a candidate accepting a counter-offer?

Ask what would make them stay before the offer, so you know what they actually want. Move fast, keep talking to them through the notice period, and do not enter a bidding war.

The takeaway

Call before you send, lead with a real number rather than an anchor, make the whole package legible, handle a counter with speed or a straight explanation, and treat the notice period as an active part of the hire rather than a waiting room.