Back to Resources
Assessment 6 min read

How to run a reference check that tells you something

A reference check that confirms employment dates has told you nothing. Specific questions, asked after a specific decision, are where the value is.

Reference checking has a reputation as a formality, and for most employers the reputation is accurate. A call is made, dates are confirmed, a vague positive is offered, the box is ticked. Nobody learns anything, and everyone involved knows it.

The reason is not that referees are unhelpful. It is that they are asked bad questions. "Would you rehire them" invites a yes. "How did they perform" invites a summary. Specific questions about specific behaviours get specific answers, and the difference is dramatic.

Do it at the right point

Run references after you have decided you want the candidate, before the offer is final, and with the candidate's knowledge and consent.

Earlier than that wastes referees' time and risks alerting a current employer. Later and you are looking for reasons to confirm a decision you have already made, which is not a check.

Always get consent, and never contact a current employer without explicit permission. Doing so can genuinely cost someone their job and will cost you the candidate.

Ask the right people

Ask for the person who directly managed them in the role that matters most. A peer or a friendly colleague will give you a pleasant conversation with very little information in it.

Two referees is usually enough if they are the right two. Five character references are not better than one former manager who can describe the work.

If a candidate cannot produce a manager from a recent, relevant role, ask why. There are good answers, including a company that no longer exists, a manager who has left, or a genuinely difficult relationship that they can explain. Take the explanation seriously and note that you asked.

The questions that produce information

Skip the ones that invite a summary. Ask about specifics.

"What did they actually own?" Establishes scope, and it is where the biggest discrepancies with a resume appear. Not usually deception, more often a candidate's generous framing of a shared responsibility.

"What did they find difficult, or what were they still working on?" Almost every referee will answer this honestly, because it is phrased as development rather than criticism. The answer is frequently the single most useful thing in the call.

"How did they handle it when something went wrong?" More informative than any question about strengths.

"What kind of environment did they do their best work in?" Genuinely useful for the decision and for the first ninety days. A referee who says "she did her best work when left alone with a clear objective" has told you how to manage them.

"Who did they work with most, and how did that go?" Surfaces working style without asking anyone to rate a personality.

"If you were hiring them again, what would you want to be sure of?" The best closing question in reference checking. It gives a referee permission to raise a genuine reservation without making an accusation, and they usually take it.

Verify one or two specifics. Pick a concrete claim from the interview and check it. "They mentioned leading the migration. What was their role in that."

Read the hesitation

Referees rarely say anything damaging directly. What they do instead is get careful, and careful is information.

Listen for someone who confirms facts warmly but will not characterise the work. Listen for a long pause before an answer about a specific area. Listen for "they were fine" delivered flatly about someone described as exceptional elsewhere.

When you hear it, do not interrogate. Ask an open follow-up and then stop talking. "Is there anything you would want a new manager to know going in?" Silence does the rest more often than pressure does.

And weigh it properly. One guarded reference against two strong ones and a solid process is a data point, not a verdict. A pattern across referees is different.

What you can and cannot ask

Reference checks are covered by employment and privacy law, and the boundaries are reasonably consistent across jurisdictions.

Ask about performance, conduct, attendance where genuinely relevant to the role, and eligibility for rehire. Do not ask about health or disability, age, family or caring arrangements, pregnancy, religion, or anything else you could not ask the candidate directly. If a referee volunteers protected information, do not record it and do not let it enter the decision.

Record what was asked and what was said, factually. Notes on a reference check are commonly disclosable, so write them as you would be content for the candidate to read them. Keep them with the rest of the hiring record, and apply the same retention rules.

Be aware that many large employers now have a policy of confirming dates and title only. That is not a signal about the candidate. It is a legal risk posture, and it is worth knowing which employers do it before you read anything into a thin reference.

Making it consistent

Reference checks suffer from the same problem as unstructured interviews. Different questions to different referees produce answers that cannot be compared, and the quality depends on who happened to make the call.

Use the same core questions for every candidate on a role, record the answers against them, and have the same person run them where you can.

HRM8's Assessment Hub includes a structured reference check at US$75 per candidate, with a job pack of three at US$165. It runs the same questions consistently and returns a structured response rather than a free-text recollection of a phone call. It is AI-scored and never auto-rejects: any adverse result routes to the employer to sign off. Reference checks are also built into Recruit and Search engagements within Recruitment Services.

Common questions

When should you check references?

After you have decided you want the candidate and before the offer is final, with their consent. Never contact a current employer without explicit permission.

How many references do you need?

Two is usually enough if they are direct former managers from relevant roles. Quality matters far more than number.

What questions should you ask a referee?

Specific ones about scope, difficulty, how the person handled something going wrong, and what environment suited them. Close with what you would want to be sure of if you were hiring them again.

What can you not ask in a reference check?

Anything you could not ask the candidate: health, disability, age, family or caring arrangements, pregnancy, religion. If volunteered, do not record it and do not act on it.

What if a referee will only confirm dates?

Many large employers have that policy for legal reasons. It is not a signal about the candidate. Weigh the rest of your evidence accordingly.

The takeaway

Check references after you have decided and before the offer closes, speak to direct former managers, ask specific questions about scope and difficulty rather than performance in general, close with what you would want to be sure of, and record only what you could defend showing the candidate.